Ashley Mooney

With Arctic ice having reached its Minimum for 2024, it is time for the annual update. My figures come from NSIDC https://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/.

2024 is the seventh lowest on record. That is to say that six years had LOWER winter sea ice minima than this year.

The last eighteen (18) years show the lowest annual arctic sea ice minimum in the satellite record (ie since 1979). However, the trend over the last eighteen years 2007 – 2024 is -0.24% per annum. That seems to me to be as close to flat as makes no difference.

With the correct use of the english language present tense, the world IS NOT warming.

Figures for annual minima are:

Arctic Ice Sheet Minima

Year	m Km2
2007	4.16
2008	4.59
2009	5.12
2010	4.62
2011	4.34
2012	3.39
2013	5.05
2014	5.03
2015	4.43
2016	4.17
2017	4.67
2018	4.66
2019	4.19
2020	3.82
2021	4.72
2022	4.67
2023	4.23
2024	4.28

Here is a graph of these figures:

The last two year’s [Labour] budget figures from the relevant BEFU (Budget Economic and Fiscal Update) showed that the extra government expenditure during Covid had been baked into every year into the future. This year’s budget, from the 2024 BEFU (Budget Economic and Fiscal Update) does, very slowly, begin to close that gap, although the figures in the first year are actually worse.

The graph below shows actual/budget expenditure (Blue) compared to what it would have been with a 4.5%pa growth rate from the pre-Covid trend (Orange). The last Labour budget is shown in Grey. A 4.5% growth on the pre-Covid trend is extremely generous – no NZ government could reasonably expect the economy to grow at 4.5% indefinitely!

The bottom line here is that government expenditure is roughly 5% higher, as a percentage of GDP, than it was pre-Covid. And the current government has not laid out a plan to return to pre-Covid expenditure levels. The government may well point to; the poor state of the government books, the poor economic outlook, and the uncertain global economic position, as reasons not to reduce government spending now. However, as it stands, this National government are doing as decent impersonation of previous National governments who talked a big game in opposition and then became “Continuity Labour” in office. New Zealanders deserve so much better.

With Arctic ice having reached its Maximum for 2024, it is time for the annual update. My figures come from NSIDC https://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index.

In the last nineteen (19) years only four years had higher maximums.

The last nineteen (19) years show the lowest annual arctic sea ice maximum in the satellite record (ie since 1979). However, the trend over the last nineteen years 2006 – 2024 is -0.11% per annum. If this trend continues arctic sea ice will decline by 0.11% in the next century. That seems to me to be as close to flat as makes no difference.

With the correct use of the english language present tense, the world IS not warming.

Figures for annual annual arctic ice sheet minima are:

Year	m Km2
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2109 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024	14.78 14.85 15.35 15.20 15.35 14.70 15.31 15.20 15.01 14.55 14.57 14.45 14.50 14.90 15.07 14.87 14.93 14.62 15.01

Here is a graph of these figures:

With Arctic ice having reached its Minimum for 2023, it is time for the annual update. My figures come from NSIDC https://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/.

2023 is the fifth lowest on record. That is to say that four years had LOWER winter sea ice minima than this year.

The last seventeen (17) years show the lowest annual arctic sea ice minimum in the satellite record (ie since 1979). However, the trend over the last sixteen years 2007 – 2023 is -0.9% per annum. That seems to me to be as close to flat as makes no difference.

With the correct use of the english language present tense, the world IS NOT warming.

Figures for annual minima are:

Arctic Ice Sheet Minima

Year	m Km2
2007	4.16
2008	4.59
2009	5.12
2010	4.62
2011	4.34
2012	3.39
2013	5.05
2014	5.03
2015	4.43
2016	4.17
2017	4.67
2018	4.66
2019	4.19
2020	3.82
2021	4.72
2022	4.67
2023	4.23

Here is a graph of these figures:

When I looked at last year’s budget figures, from the 2022 BEFU (Budget Economic and Fiscal Update) , I found that the extra government expenditure during Covid has been baked into every year into the future. This year’s budget, from the 2023 BEFU (Budget Economic and Fiscal Update) , continues that trend, only worse.

The graph below shows actual expenditure compared to what it would have been with a 4.5%pa growth rate from the pre-Covid trend. The government is making no attempt to return to the pre-Covid trend line.

The government chooses to represent numbers either as a percentage of GDP or in terms of net debt. Both these approaches have wriggle room for the government as the first allows them to use heroic GDP forecasts (over 5% every year), and the later allows them the change the way net debt is calculated.

The bottom line here is that we deserve to be told what we are getting for all this extra expenditure. That is not happening. New Zealander’s deserve so much better!

With Arctic ice having reached its Maximum for 2023, it is time for the annual update. My figures come from NSIDC https://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index.

2023 is the fifth lowest on record. That is to say that four years had LOWER winter sea ice maxima that this year.

The last eighteen (18) years show the lowest annual arctic sea ice maximum in the satellite record (ie since 1979). However, the trend over the last sixteen years 2006 – 2023 is -0.15% per annum. That seems to me to be as close to flat as makes no difference.

With the correct use of the english language present tense, the world IS not warming.

Figures for annual annual arctic ice sheet minima are:

Year	m Km2
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2109 2020 2021 2022 2023	14.78 14.85 15.35 15.20 15.35 14.70 15.31 15.20 15.01 14.55 14.57 14.45 14.50 14.90 15.07 14.87 14.93 14.62

Here is a graph of these figures:

When I looked at figures from the 2022 BEFU (Budget Economic and Fiscal Update) and the Financial Statements of the Government of New Zealand for the year ended 30 June 2021 I found that the extra government expenditure during Covid has been baked into every year into the future. This amounts to an extra $25bn per year of total Crown Expenditure, which compares with the actual figure for 2021 of $133bn – a 19% increase. This take government expenditure from 35.5% to 42.1% as a percentage of GDP.

	NZD bn	Change
2015 Actual	93,064	–
2016 Actual	95,137	2.2%
2017 Actual	99,007	4.1%
2018 Actual	104,014	5.1%
2019 Actual	111,376	7.1%
2020 Actual	138,916	24.7%
2021 Actual	133,722	-3.7%
2022 Budget	154,887	15.8%
2023 Budget	158,528	2.4%
2024 Budget	163,508	3.1%
2025 Budget	167,872	2.7%
2026 Budget	177,254	5.6%

One might have expected total Crown Expenditure to fall after Covid. After all the costs of the vaccination program and furlough do not continue. However, in New Zealand government expenditure continues as if these costs are to be incurred every year into the future. Below I graph what Total Crown Expenditure would have been with annual growth of 4.5%pa from 2019.

The government is making no attempt to return to the pre-Covid trend line. And there has been no attempt to explain what we are getting for this [massive] extra expenditure.

With Arctic ice having reached its Minimum for 2022, it is time for the annual update. My figures come from NSIDC https://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/.

2022 tied with 2010 as the eleventh lowest on record. That is to say that ten years had LOWER winter sea ice maxima that this year.

The last sixteen (16) years show the lowest annual arctic sea ice minimum in the satellite record (ie since 1979). However, the trend over the last sixteen years 2006 – 2022 is -0.05% per annum. That seems to me to be as close to flat as makes no difference.

With the correct use of the english language present tense, the world IS not warming.

Figures for annual minima are:

Arctic Ice Sheet Minima

Year	m Km2
2007	4.16
2008	4.59
2009	5.12
2010	4.62
2011	4.34
2012	3.39
2013	5.05
2014	5.03
2015	4.43
2016	4.17
2017	4.67
2018	4.66
2019	4.19
2020	3.82
2021	4.72
2022	4.67

Here is a graph of these figures:

With Arctic ice having reached its Maximum for 2022, it is time for the annual update. My figures come from NSIDC https://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/.

2022 is the tenth lowest on record. That is to say that nine years had LOWER winter sea ice maxima that this year.

The last sixteen (16) years show the lowest annual arctic sea ice maximum in the satellite record (ie since 1979). However, the trend over the last sixteen years 2006 – 2022 is -0.13% per annum. That seems to me to be as close to flat as makes no difference.

With the correct use of the english language present tense, the world IS not warming.

Figures for annual minima are:

Arctic Ice Sheet Minima

Year	m Km2
2006	14.78
2007	14.85
2008	15.35
2009	15.20
2010	15.35
2011	14.70
2012	15.31
2013	15.20
2014	15.01
2015	14.55
2016	14.57
2017	14.45
2018	14.50
2019	14.90
2020	15.07
2021	14.87
2022	14.93

Here is a graph of these figures:

With Arctic ice having reached its September minimum, it is time for the annual update. My figures come from NSIDC https://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/

The last fifteen (15) years show the lowest annual arctic sea ice minima in the satellite record (ie since 1979). However,the trend over these years 2007 – 2021 is -0.26% per annum. That seems to me to be as close to flat as makes no difference. The only years, in the last 15 years, with higher sea ice minima were 2009, 2013 and 2014.

With the correct use of the english language present tense, the world IS not warming.

Figures for annual minima are:

Arctic Ice Sheet Minima

Year	m Km2
2007	4.16
2008	4.59
2009	5.12
2010	4.62
2011	4.34
2012	3.39
2013	5.05
2014	5.03
2015	4.43
2016	4.17
2017	4.67
2018	4.66
2019	4.19
2020	3.82
2021	4.72

Here is a graph of these figures alongside graphs for the previous two 14 year periods, back to 1979.